Friday, June 26, 2015


What do you think of when you think of homesteading the West? I think of families or lone men. However, in Marcia Meredith Hensley’s book. STAKING HER CLAIM: WOMEN HOMESTEADING THE WEST, I learned that many lone women became homesteaders.

I read the Women of Paragon Springs series, by Irene Bennett Brown, and loved the stories of women making their way West to set up their homes. What I didn’t realize, though, was how true-to-life Ms Brown’s fictional stories were.

Paragon Springs series, book one

Ms Hensley’s book relates many women settling in Wyoming Territory. And why not? Wyoming was far ahead of the rest of America in recognizing a woman’s right to vote and other basic rights. But other stories take place in Montana, South Dakota, North Dakota, Idaho, Colorado, and Utah.

As you can imagine, these women set out for the West for various reasons. Some were ill-equipped for the hardships. Others flourished in their new enterprise.  Ms Hensley includes letters written back East by some of the women homesteaders telling of their experiences. Fact or fiction?

“On the whole, women who wrote about their experiences homesteading alone told positive stories. . . Although homesteading was difficult, they achieved success and had many enjoyable adventures as well. Women could do most of the work themselves, but, if necessary, they could count on help from neighbors, family, or one of the many men in the vicinity.”

Only about one in three women who homesteaded actually succeeded. In a 1921 article about her homesteading experience in Utah, Kate Keizer includes a section titled “Not All Roses” in which she cautions that for the typical homesteader without much money “the first two or three years are usually accompanied by privation and hardships.” She lists difficulties such as the high cost of freighting in supplies and having your claim contested if you were absent very long. Her greatest torments were the hordes of rabbits and prairie dogs that destroyed gardens in spite of scarecrows, guns, and poison.

Looking back on her homestead experience, Dr. Bessie Rehwinkle tempered her account of the exhilarating experience of becoming a Wyoming landowner with the admission that “it is not as easy or glamorous as the storybooks about the westward trek of the covered wagon often picture it. It is a slow process and a hard day-to-day struggle, and only the strongest are able to survive.”

The Homestead Act was in force from 1862 through 1976 (with a ten year extension for Alaska). Statistics provided by the National Homestead Monument suggest two million people attempted to earn a patent on land through the Homestead Act. Ms Hensley theorizes that 200,000 of these were women, of which 67.500 may have proved up on their claim.

I suggest reading Marcia Meredith Hensley’s book for fascinating non-fiction accounts of successful women homesteaders. For fictional accounts, nothing beats Irene Bennett Brown’s Women of Paragon Springs series: LONG ROAD TURNING, BLUE HORIZONS, NO OTHER PLACE, and REAP THE SOUTH WIND. In fact, LONG ROAD TURNING is one of my favorite books and the detail reminds me of Sweethearts' member Linda Hubalek's TRAIL OF THREAD, Trail of Thread series book one. 

True, the books are different in that LONG ROAD TURNING begins as a woman alone while TRAIL OF THREAD is a woman with a family, but the accuracy of the time period and subject matter is impressive. Both bring out the mores of the time (which favored men) and both show women determined to succeed against difficult odds. The other books in Linda's great series are THIMBLE OF SOIL and STITCH OF COURAGE.

What about you? Would you have attempted to claim your land alone?

Caroline Clemmons's latest single release is O'NEILL'S TEXAS BRIDE, available in ebook from Amazon, Apple, Nook, and Kobo and available in print from Amazon, CreateSpace, and Barnes and Noble. One of her novellas is included in the recently released box set, WILD WESTERN WOMEN RIDE AGAIN, available from Amazon for Kindle for 99 cents.  


  1. I love strong heroines, and really enjoyed this post. So often pioneer women are overlooked in history and books. Homesteading took a person of strength, courage, and determination -- male or female. I think of my great-grandmother who had 11 children; one died in infancy and the other 10 grew up to be remarkable people. She came to Texas with her husband from Kentucky with the first four of those children in a covered wagon. I think what I liked so much about the Laura Ingalls Wilder books as a child was that they came from a girl's perspective. Through her voice and experience, little girls were able to relate to her, and what it must have been like to be a young girl in that time period. To understand what it was like for a pioneer woman, especially one homesteading, is important. Great post, Carolyn. I am definitely going to read these books! :)

  2. By the way, I love the cover to O'Neill's Texas Bride. She has a sweet face and I want to know more about her, and her story. :) ~ Ashley

  3. I think any woman with the courage to go west was strong. I keep thinking about the rabbits in the garden. I say shoot Mr. Rabbit and put him in the pot with some of those carrots and peas he was trying to steal.
    I can't imagine how horrid it must have been living in a soddy type house with the underground creatures. Ick!
    Thank goodness those women met the west with such courage though for the sake of future generations. A wonderful blog, Caroline.

  4. These all sound like good reads. Women who accomplished what these women did sure had grit! Thanks for such an informative post.


  5. Carolyn, you confirmed what I have suspected from my own research. Women in the West weren't all dependent on husbands to settle and succeed in their new lives. We women can do a lot for ourselves!

    Love your books and covers! O'Neill's Texas Bride is on my Kindle. I loved the first book in this series, The Texan's Irish Bride!

  6. Great post, Caroline! I would like to think I could have struck out on my own and settled land, but at the same time I don't know if I'd have had the fortitude. That's why I like to write about strong women who do take on the odds and win. The books sound interesting.


Thank you for visiting Sweethearts of the West! We are very sad to require comment moderation now due to the actions of a few spam comments. Thank you for your patience.