Friday, January 26, 2018


This is the legend of an unusual woman. Sally Newman, the woman later called “Mustang Jane” by her vaqueros, was born in Illinois in 1817 to Rachel (nee Rabb) and Joseph Newman. Her parents followed her maternal grandparents through several states to eventually settle in southeastern Texas and become part of Stephen F. Austin’s “Old Three Hundred.” (If you’re not familiar with Texas history, Stephen F. Austin’s 300 is a Big Deal here.) As a pioneer wife, Mrs. Newman was no stranger to conflict. On at least two occasions, she reportedly thwarted attacks from Comanche or Apache with quick and decisive action while young Sally watched.

Longhorn cattle

When Sally was sixteen, she registered the brand for the cattle she had inherited from her father. Although she registered the brand in her maiden name, she noted on the application that she was the wife of Jesse Robinson, a man eighteen years her senior. The alliance lasted for ten years. Custody of their children, Nancy and Alfred, was ceded to Jesse when the couple divorced in 1843. Sally kidnapped Nancy, but was forced to return her to Jesse.

Sally’s luck with her second, third, fourth, and fifth husbands was no better. She went by the last name of her second husband, Sally Scull. It was while she was married to George Scull (sometimes spelled Skull) that she developed her love for and interest in horsetrading.

Horses of the type Sally wanted

While she was losing husbands (with some speculation that she might have assisted a couple of them in departing this life), Sally was gaining a reputation for marksmanship. Whether in skirts or pants, she always wore two pistols belted to her waist and usually wore a bonnet. She was a dead shot with both pistol and rifle, in either hand. A tiny woman with steel blue eyes, she weighed 125 pounds at most. Her rough language was notorious, and she spoke Tex-Mex as well as if it were her native tongue. 

When she wasn’t traveling alone, Sally rode in the company of several Mexican vaqueros. She roamed the wide territory between the Sabine River and the Rio Grande, making her headquarters at a small settlement called Banquette, about twenty miles west of Corpus Christi. The vaqueros who worked for her and other Mexicans who knew her called her “Juana Mestena,” Mustang Jane. She could outshoot any of her ranch hands, roped and rode with the best of them, and could drive a herd better than any of the wranglers in her employ.

I doubt Sally Scull was this
cute, don't you?

Horsetrading was her primary business, a profitable one, and often under questionable circumstances. After a trip into Mexico, she supposedly always returned with a nice herd of stock, yet her money belt was still full. Sally knew all the ranches in the area. Ranch wives sometimes hinted that while Sally made eyes at the menfolk, her vaqueros were busy cutting the best horses from the herd. There were also rumors that she had assistance from the Comanche. If Sally admired particular horses and the owner refused to sell, Comanche raiders mysteriously visited the ranch shortly after Sally’s departure. No one ever caught Sally in possession of a horse for which she couldn’t show rightful ownership because she never let anyone inspect her herd.

Sally worked hard and played hard. She was an avid poker player and her favorite haunts included Old St. Mary’s Saloon at Copano Bay, Pancho Grande’s in Corpus Christi, and several places in Refugio. She attended many a fandango due to her love of dancing. Can’t you imagine her dancing while wearing those two pistols belted around her waist?

During the Civil War, Sally’s knowledge of the southern Texas backcountry served the Confederacy. Union forces blockaded Texas ports, stopping all shipments from England. The United States could not block ports south of the border, so Mexico’s ports were open. Sally sold her stock of horses, bought wagons, and turned her vaqueros into cotton haulers. 

Cotton freighting

Sally's wagons became a common sight on the roads from San Antonio to Matamoros on what became known as the Cotton Road. Cotton was traded in Matamoros for guns, ammunition, medicines, coffee, shoes, clothing and other goods vital to the Confederacy and needed by inland Texas settlements. When the war ended in 1865, Sally sold her wagons and resumed the horse business.

Sally had little to do with her son, Alfred, who lived with his father and stepmother and their eight children on Ramerania Creek, about fifty miles northwest of Corpus Christi. No one knows what happened to Alfred Robinson. Nancy and her mother were closer. Sally sent her to one of the best boarding schools in New Orleans. Nancy returned to Texas, married, and lived up to her mother’s dreams. They were close until one visit when one of Nancy’s family dogs growled at Sally and she shot the dog.

No one knows what happened to Sally Scull. Texas mothers used to cajole their children to behave or “Old Sally Skull will get you.” Not a nice remembrance, but Sally Scull had defied all expectations of womanhood for her era or any other. She walked tall in a world of strong men and made anyone in her path step aside. 

Sources: Wikipedia
FROM ANGELS TO HELLCATS: Legendary Texas Women 1835-1880, By Don Blevins

Caroline Clemmons is an award winning Amazon bestselling author of western romance. Find her books listed on her Amazon Author Page and like her there. Sign up for her newsletter for a free novella, HAPPY IS THE BRIDE.


  1. Good old Sally. What a woman! Never heard of her, but now I know who she was. Caroline, you have a great knack for ferreting out characters we should know about--but don't. Thanks for telling us...and warning us...about Old Sally Skull!

    1. Neither of us have children of the age to threaten--not that we would if we did--so her threat won't help us. She certainly knew the secret to marrying... and marrying.

  2. Interesting post, Caroline. Wish you had a picture of her. Boy, guns and a sunbonnet. What a picture that paints. You need to write a book using her as your character.

  3. Intriguing character if not very nice! Thanks for a unique story, Caroline.

  4. Wow, Sally may have been a bad girl and a bit underhanded in her business practices, but I have to say, her life sounds so exciting and she certainly had a lot of friends willing to help her. And I love that, devious as she may have been, she was brilliant.
    Great post, Caroline!


Thank you for visiting Sweethearts of the West! We are very sad to require comment moderation now due to the actions of a few spam comments. Thank you for your patience.